Reviews and Comments

plinytheolder

plinytheolder@sfba.club

Joined 10 months, 3 weeks ago

This link opens in a pop-up window

Shannon Chakraborty: The Adventures of Amina Al-Sirafi (2023, HarperCollins Publishers) 5 stars

Amina al-Sirafi should be content. After a storied and scandalous career as one of the …

Legendary Pirate Queen

5 stars

I was thoroughly charmed by this book — an adventure-filled, magical story of a pirate queen who became a legend. It took an era that I know nothing about — the seafaring cultures of the 12th century Indian Ocean, especially focused on Oman, Yemen, and Somalia, as filtered through the 1001 Nights, and gave it a contemporary twist by focusing on the glorious Amina al-Sarafi. She’s a Muslim former pirate who has retired to raise her daughter, but gets pulled into One Last Heist by being offered an eye-popping sum of money to go rescue the kidnapped child of one of her former crew. An early chapter in which she successfully defends two idiots who are looking for treasure from an angry sea demon sets the tone for later encounters with creatures more and more magical. Amina has a live-and-let-live attitude toward her queer crew members, which is refreshing. The …

Tansy Rayner Roberts: Gate Sinister (Paperback, 2023, Tansy Rayner Roberts) 5 stars

Cute gaslamp fantasy novella

5 stars

I liked one of Tansy Rayner Roberts other fantasy series, so I gave this — the first in a series — a go, and it was good! It’s a gaslamp fantasy novella — obviously inspired by Jane Austen and other regency romances, but in an alternate 1870s Britannia, a couple centuries after Queen Elizabeth won a war against the Queen of the Fairies.

There’s a second volume out now, and two more due out this year or next.

Kim Stanley Robinson: Shaman (Paperback, 2014, imusti, Orbit) 5 stars

engrossing historical fiction

5 stars

KSR always writes compelling science fiction; this is a bit of a departure — it’s historical fiction set in the Neolithic period in France, about a shaman’s apprentice in a time when early humans live alongside Neanderthals, and mammoth, rhinoceros, bison, lions, leopards and other now-extinct animals are a constant presence.

reviewed Mistletoe and Mishigas by M.A. Wardell (Teachers in Love, #2)

M.A. Wardell: Mistletoe and Mishigas 5 stars

Absolutely lovely Hanukkah (and Christmas) themed spicy romcom.

5 stars

I finished this about an hour before midnight on New Year’s Eve, and the next morning my spouse and I had a mini bookclub conversation about what we loved about both books in this Teachers in Love series. Mistletoe & Mishigas is a standalone, although characters from the first book do make cameo appearances, and is my favorite of the two — you could totally start here if you like.

I really liked the alternating point-of-view structure of this novel, because I found both leads to be adorable in their own ways and appreciated their perspectives. The holiday aspect added fun. The spiciness was just about perfect as well. I’m looking forward to the next book in the series.

S. A. Cosby: All the Sinners Bleed (2023, Flatiron Books) 5 stars

Fantastic crime novel

5 stars

This is the third S.A. Cosby book I’ve read — all are set in rural Black Virginia, all are very violent to be clear, and all incredible. I don’t read a whole lot of crime, but he’s one of my favorites.

The first Black sheriff in a rural Virginia county is called out to a school shooting of a beloved white teacher by a young Black man; the shooter is killed by two white deputies. The investigation reveals that a serial killer has been at work for a long time.

Geoff Ryman: Him (2023, Watkins Media Limited) 5 stars

stunning

5 stars

A compelling retelling of the story of Jesus of Nazareth.

When Maryam, a virgin and wife of Yosef, gives birth, it’s a miracle child: a beautiful girl. But at age 5, the child proclaims: “I am a boy. My name now is Yehushua.” Yosef accepts this, but Maryam cannot quite bring herself to do so.

Ryman captures better than anyone I’ve ever read what it would be like to live in the absolute poverty of first century Galilee, how it’d feel to follow a charismatic teacher, what miracles might feel like, how it might be to have the God of all creation folded down into the mind of one peasant from a nowhere town.

I’ll be thinking about this book for a long long time.