Reviews and Comments

bluestocking

bluestocking@sfba.club

Joined 2 years, 1 month ago

White queer lady in San Francisco. Knitter, transit geek, and sometime editor and cyclist. Planting peas and potatoes to prefigure an anarchist future. I listen to a lot of nonfiction audiobooks.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Sarah Hill: This Is Your Brain on Birth Control: The Surprising Science of Women, Hormones, and the Law of Unintended Consequences (2019, Avery Publishing Group)

This was incredibly informative, and made me feel hopeful that research related to birth control and those that use it is becoming more of a going concern. I learned a lot reading this, but was also left curious about where the research stands now, and wondering if most of society is even ready to have the complex conversation this book starts. I'm going to be sitting with this one for a while. Highly recommend reading this if you use hormonal birth control or are planning to start it.

My main issues with the book were things I kind of expected out of this--gender essentialism (which, again, to be expected, but there are points where it's quite excessive), more speculation on the meaning of certain research than is warranted (e.g., "not having women who are ovulating around them is leading to men becoming less ambitious" with very thin/nonexistent research to support …

Matthew Desmond: Poverty, by America (2023, Crown Publishing Group, The)

Review of 'Poverty, by America' on 'Storygraph'

This is a fairly short book, and thus far from comprehensive. I was expecting something more similar to Desmond's previous work, Evicted, with more focus on in-depth statistics and interviews with individuals. This definitely utilizes some statistics and historical information, as well as brief anecdotes, but this work feels more like a persuasive essay rather than offering concrete information. While I don't disagree with most of what Desmond says (aside from feeling like the solutions he asks for are a bit too centrist and not nearly radical enough), I also don't feel like I really learned anything new.

If you're relatively new to learning about how poverty affects people in the United States and the various systems involved, as well as possible solutions, this is a solid primer.