Reviews and Comments

Phil in SF

kingrat@sfba.club

Joined 1 year, 8 months ago

aka @kingrat@sfba.social. I'm following a lot of bookwyrm accounts, since that seems to be the only way to get reviews from larger servers to this small server. Also, I will like & boost a lot of reviews that come across my feed. I will follow most bookwyrm accounts back if they review & comment. Social reading should be social.

2024 In The Books

This link opens in a pop-up window

Naomi Novik: His Majesty's Dragon (EBook, 2006, Del Rey / Ballantine)

Aerial combat brings a thrilling new dimension to the Napoleonic Wars as valiant warriors rise …

Not my thing after all

The origin story of the dragon Temeraire, captured from the French by the captain of an English ship, William Laurence. The person who drew the short straw is rejected as a rider by Temeraire, and Laurence becomes the rider in his place, but must give up his career in the navy. Training and battles in the dragon air service follow.

It is well-written, but the extended treatment of the proper relationship between riders and dragons was not interesting enough for me to want to seek out the sequels. People who like tales of manners will find this more enjoyable.

commented on Promises Stronger Than Darkness by Charlie Jane Anders (Unstoppable, #3)

Charlie Jane Anders: Promises Stronger Than Darkness (Hardcover, 2023, Tor Teen)

They're the galaxy's most wanted—and our only hope.

When Elza became a space princess, she …

started reading His Majesty's Dragon by Naomi Novik (Temeraire, #1)

Naomi Novik: His Majesty's Dragon (EBook, 2006, Del Rey / Ballantine)

Aerial combat brings a thrilling new dimension to the Napoleonic Wars as valiant warriors rise …

This has been on my TBR for 15 years. I originally got the ebook as a freebie from suvudu.com, a long defunct site run by Penguin or Random House (I forget which company owned the Del Rey imprint before the merger). Let's finally take a crack at it.

Paul Krugman: Arguing with Zombies (EBook, 2020, W.W. Norton)

An accessible, compelling introduction to today’s major policy issues from the New York Times columnist, …

when i picked this up i thought it was new writing. it's actually old columns of his. they were great when i read them the first time. not really interested in re-reading them, particularly the ones from the Bush era.

reviewed Never Go Back by Lee Child (Jack Reacher, #18)

Lee Child: Never Go Back (EBook, 2013, Delacorte)

Former military cop Jack Reacher makes it all the way from snowbound South Dakota to …

Serviceable Reacher again

Never Go Back has a simpler conspiracy than the previous book, A Wanted Man, and it meant I could actually enjoy this one. The bad guys mess with Reacher, setting him up to take a fall for a murder he did not commit. This sets up a cat-and-mouse between Reacher and the baddies, as he escapes, dodges the fuzz & the henchmen, tries to rescue the girl, and gets down & dirty with the woman he decided he wanted to meet something like 4 books ago.

commented on White Sky, Black Ice by Stan Jones (Nathan Active, #1)

Stan Jones: White Sky, Black Ice (Paperback, 2003, Soho Crime)

In the small Alaskan village of Chukchi, what are the odds of two suicides occurring …

The woman sitting at the counter next to me at The Pork Store this morning was reading White Sky, Black Ice. I mentioned reading and liking it. Because it's not a well known book, it sparked a long discussion of our favorite authors.

reviewed High Heat by Lee Child (Jack Reacher, #17.5)

Lee Child: High Heat (EBook, 2013, Delacorte)

July 1977. Jack Reacher is almost seventeen, and he stops in New York City on …

Young Jack Racher goes from Korea to NYC and takes down the mob

Also, he's in high school but so cool he picks up college girls.

As before, young Reacher is even less believable than adult Reacher. Very meh on this story.

Nancy Kress, Therese Pieczynski: New Under the Sun (EBook, 2013, Phoenix Pick)

Set in the near future, Nancy Kress’ story gives us a world increasingly hostile to …

Standard Kress fare

Kress likes to do "what if human bodies were changed..." stories. This one is: what if a symbiotic species inhabited a human such that it could make changes to the host but the person and symbiote could only communicate in a general sense. So the symbiote can make its host able to spit toxic saliva when threatened, or change the host's pigment and apparent age, etc. Set in an era where there's a breakdown in civil society because large numbers of US residents believe in witches (and want to burn them at the stake).

The Pieczynski piece features a woman in 1980s Sandinista Nicaragua who focuses the energy of the fighting between Contras and Sandinistas and turns it into sentient whirlwinds and golems.

Katarina Bivald: The Murders in Great Diddling (AudiobookFormat, 2024, Dreamscape Audio)

The best stories are the ones we didn’t know needed to be told.

The small, …

Cozy mystery with a bit of police procedural

While attending a tea party in Great Diddling, author Berit Gardner witnesses the murder of Reginald Trent in the manor of his aunt, Daphne Trent. Reginald Trent is pretty universally disliked in the village of Great Diddling. Everyone there dislikes him. Berit Gardner, wanting to avoid writing her next book, investigates instead. Meanwhile the townsfolk, lead by tourist board chair, decide to take advantage of their sudden notoriety by holding a books & murders literary festival on short notice. At the center of the crime is who controls the books of Tawny Hall, Daphne Trent's massive collection.

It's a cozy mystery. It's a bit of a police procedural. It's an homage to readers, though there precious little of the point of view of readers. All the town's characters have backstories. My main nitpick is the ultimate solution to the mystery of the murder follows a pretty standard pattern, so whodunnit …

C. M. Alongi: Citadel (EBook, 2023, Blackstone)

In this luminous sci-fi debut, a nonverbal autistic woman refuses to crumble as she stands …

clumsy, without any subtlety

Content warning spoiler review

Jeremy P. Bushnell: Relentless Melt (EBook, 2023, Melville House)

Stranger Things meets the Golden Age of Detective fiction in a rollicking supernatural detective thriller …

Fun coming of age story

Relentless Melt starts off with young Artie Quick attending their first investigation class at a night school for young men run by the Y.M.C.A. The teacher, an older policeman, observes that Artie appears to be a young woman wearing a young man's suit, making them ineligible for the class. Nevertheless, he seems inclined to keep Artie's secret.

Artie is taking the class to, as they later figure out, make sense of why their brother Zeb has abandoned the family for a life of crime. But at the outset Artie thinks they're intrigued by solving crimes. And so Artie and their best friend Theodore, a young adult with family money but living on his own, decide to practice solving crimes by investigating a scream heard in a local park late at night.

The book is a little bit coming of age, a little bit amateur sleuths solving a mystery, and a …