Reviews and Comments

Phil in SF

kingrat@sfba.club

Joined 1 year, 3 months ago

aka @kingrat@sfba.social. I'm following a lot of bookwyrm accounts, since that seems to be the only way to get reviews from larger servers to this small server. Also, I will like & boost a lot of reviews that come across my feed. I will follow most bookwyrm accounts back if they review & comment. Social reading should be social.

2024 In The Books

This link opens in a pop-up window

reviewed Cop Hater by Ed McBain (87th Precinct, #1)

Ed McBain: Cop Hater (Hardcover, 1990, Armchair Detective Library) 3 stars

Cop Hater (1956) is the first 87th Precinct police procedural novel by Ed McBain. The …

The pulpiest of police procedurals

3 stars

Three detectives are killed in quick succession in Isola, a fictionalized version of New York City. Fictionalized, according to the author, so he could take liberties with how the cops in New York City actually operate. Full of dames and men who appreciate the swell of a woman's chest and gangs that rumble, cops that harass suspects based on hunches, having a drink or two on the job and a general lack of respect for the Bill of Rights that predated the Warren court. The crime is solved through luck, accumulating evidence (I like this part) and a not very smart impatient criminal. There's a lot of copaganda in it, but the police are not portrayed as being particularly smart.

Lois McMaster Bujold: The Warrior's Apprentice (EBook, 2018, Spetrum Literary Agency) 4 stars

Discharged from the Barrayan Military Academy, Miles Vorkosigan chances on a jumpship with a rebellious …

How To Lead A Military Without Trying

3 stars

Miles Vorkosigan washes out military school and heads to another planetary system to spend time with his grandmother and her family. There he decides to bail out some down & outers using his name and a bit of family money and do some smuggling/inter system trade to recover the money. Things go poorly and the only way through each obstacle is bluffing, and at every step he succeeds but has to face every larger obstacles afterward.

As a sci-fi adventure plot, it's adequate. But Miles "I'm a nice guy using my position to try to get in the pants of the woman who reports to me" vibe really brought me down. At least the character who raped women in the previous book wasn't given a "I was just following orders and feel bad about" pass from the narrative. Which it seemed like it would. There's still some amount of "we …

reviewed Birdman by Mo Hayder (Jack Caffery, #1)

Mo Hayder: Birdman (EBook, 2012, Grove Press) 4 stars

In his first case as lead investigator with London’s crack murder squad, Detective Jack Caffery …

Enjoyable police procedural

4 stars

First in a series, where Jack Caffery is the new detective in the unit and gets a case where 4 bodies of prostitutes are found buried in a shallow grave. Suspicion falls on a few different folks. The author includes a few chapters from the perspective of the criminal in a fairly transparent try at misleading the reader. Once you get to the twist, you'll see it too. Enjoyable for me because the detective work is less movie plot magic wandism and more basic forensics. However, there's a fair amount of sensationalism. And as for the crime itself, many aspects of it seem unlikely and overly intricate to further the sensationalism and plot twists.

reviewed Shards of Honor by Lois McMaster Bujold (Vorkosigan Saga, #1)

Lois McMaster Bujold: Shards of Honor (EBook, 2018, Spectrum Literary Agency) 4 stars

When Cordelia Naismith and her survey crew are attacked by a renegade group from Barrayar, …

Enemies to lovers

3 stars

Cordelia Naismith's science team is ambushed by a Barrayaran military unit while conducting a survey of what they thought was an unclaimed world. In a double-cross, some in the unit mutiny and strand their leader Aral Vorkosigan on the planet as well. Vorkosigan, known as the butcher of Komarr for slaughtering innocent people there, has claims to wanting a bloodless capture. In order to survive, both of them must trek tens of kilometers to a claimed supply cache and learn to trust each other.

Thus begins a number of encounters between Cordelia and Aral, interspersed with a few scenes of Cordelia on her own. Nobody believes her that she thinks Aral is different. And will Aral be forced by his war-like society to live up to the stereotypes with respect to Cordelia?

I'm not going to explicitly spoil this, but this follows romance rules in a very romance inspired book. …

commented on Birdman by Mo Hayder (Jack Caffery, #1)

Mo Hayder: Birdman (EBook, 2012, Grove Press) 4 stars

In his first case as lead investigator with London’s crack murder squad, Detective Jack Caffery …

Content warning spoiler for what's happened so far

reviewed A Kiss of Shadows by Laurell K. Hamilton (Merry Gentry, #1)

Laurell K. Hamilton: A Kiss of Shadows (EBook, 2001, Ballantine Books) 2 stars

Merry Gentry, princess of the high court of Faerie, is posing as a human in …

Tedious

2 stars

There's a lot of sex in the first 31% (according to Kobo) of this book and I have to put it down because writing that makes sex this tedious ain't for me.

So far, Merry Gentry:

  • gets a microphone implanted in her bra with a roomful of men, many of whom leer because it's just polite to harass a faery
  • goes undercover and we get a magically caused but still lustful rape including a mysterious magical faery occluded in a darkened mirror and spiders
  • a near orgy when being questioned by skeptical police
  • magical sex that restores a seal faery's ability to become a seal again
  • an exhibitionist shower scene for the benefit of the boss
  • a boring ass chase scene on Sepulveda Blvd where unseen monsters poke holes in the side of a van
  • and an I'll show you mine if you show me yours scene with a stomach …

reviewed Everywhere You Look by Liv Constantine (Never Tell Collection, #1)

Liv Constantine: Everywhere You Look (EBook, 2024, Amazon Original Stories) 2 stars

All it takes is one shocking revelation on a New York street for a woman …

Flat & uncreative

2 stars

Jade's life has been unraveling since her father died a decade ago. A rare illness causes her to drop out of medical school track. A breakup with a shitty self-help guru leaves Jade effectively homeless. And then, Jade sees her father through the window of a restaurant on her annual pilgrimage to New York City to remember him. Could her father be alive?

Cardboard-thin caricatures for the characters in this story, and card-board thin machinations comprise the plot, and the last third of the book is exposition on what really happened and that's done in a flat and uncreative fashion.

Charlie Jane Anders: The Fermi Paradox Is Our Business Model (EBook, 2010, Tor.com) 4 stars

Jon and Toku travel the universe suspended in Interdream, only waking up to check up …

We are the product of aliens

4 stars

A pair of aliens show up to Earth expecting a planet where humans have killed each other off and they can harvest all the leftovers. The incredulity of the aliens toward the still living humans reminds me a bit of They're Made of Out of Meat by Terry Bisson.

Carolyn Ives Gilman: Arkfall (EBook, 2010, Phoenix Pick) 4 stars

Humans live deep within an apparently lifeless planet covered by massive ice sheets. Having to …

Exploring a water planet

4 stars

Osaji feels stifled by life on Benn, a water planet where humans live in biological arks that float beneath the surface and which supply their needs in the water environment. Benn is very polite, and people are not adventurous. Jack Halliday is an offworlder stuck on Benn for some reason which I've forgotten, and he feels even more stifled.

A disaster strikes the cluster of arks, and Osaji, her grandmother Mota, and Jack find themselves on a disconnected ark outside the protected gulf where everyone lives. They get to go on an adventures, reconcile their differing viewpoints on life, and along the way get to view the unknown life that populates the wilder parts of the Bennite ocean that noone has ever encountered.

Solid hard-SF novella. Everyone has a personality, even if they are a bit archetypical. Fun imagining of a human society and its biological support that could be …