Reviews and Comments

Steven Ray

stevenray@sfba.club

Joined 1 year, 1 month ago

I’m interested in a multitude of things, including social justice, socialism, history, poetry, magical realism (fiction), capitalism, race, class struggle, wine, baseball, music…

So mostly non-fiction, though I read maybe two novels per year.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Stuart Hall, David Morley: Essential Essays, Volume 1 (2019, Duke University Press) 5 stars

From his arrival in Britain in the 1950s and involvement in the New Left, to …

To me, this book is so crucial to understanding the media, politics and culture. You have to climb the mountain of Stuart’s vocabulary if, like me, your own is of a more pedestrian variety. But his perspective on how things ‘are’ and how we got here, even when some of these essays are several decades old, is so insightful. I’m very glad that I read this. Thanks for the education.

Frederic Gros, David Fernbach: Disobey! (Paperback, 2021, Verso Books) 4 stars

The world is out of joint, so much so that disobeying should be an urgent …

A way to be true to ourselves

4 stars

In this age when so much is wrong with the world, Frédéric Gros seeks to convince us that by obeying others we disobey ourselves. Also, that our highest calling is to defend the community that we are a part of, our human community. By undertaking a habit of civil disobedience, we resist injustice. When we speak up for ourselves, we speak up for the whole of humanity.

He references people as diverse as Thoreau and Eichmann, Antigone and Kant, Foucault and la Boétie, finishing with Socrates and Plato. Describing the various ways we justify to ourselves the continuation of our docility, this obeisance to authority which we’ve practiced since childhood, he seeks avenues through which we can finally be true to ourselves.

I’d say he succeeds, if only we’ll take his lesson to heart.