I'd like to note that there's nothing inherently wrong with this classic. Tolkien paved the way for high fantasy and has inspired so many phenomenal works of fiction, from novels to films to tabletop RPGs. But the narrative style of The Lord of the Rings is dry and was difficult to engage with after the hobbits left the Shire. I respect Tolkien and am certain my stories would be vastly different without his influence, but I'd much rather watch the condensed and visually striking films than slog through another thirty hours of text. I understand the draw and loyalty of Tolkien's biggest fans, he simply isn't for me. After struggling through the text for weeks, I finally called it at the 25% mark.
User Profile
aka @kingrat@sfba.social. I'm following a lot of bookwyrm accounts, since that seems to be the only way to get reviews from larger servers to this small server. I make a lot of Bookwyrm lists. I will like & boost a lot of reviews that come across my feed. I will follow most bookwyrm accounts back if they review & comment. Social reading should be social.
This link opens in a pop-up window
Phil in SF's books
2026 Reading Goal
20% complete! Phil in SF has read 6 of 30 books.
User Activity
RSS feed Back
Amber Herbert reviewed The Lord of the Rings by J. R. R. Tolkien
Phil in SF started reading Beautiful Children by Charles Bock
Phil in SF reviewed 212 by Alafair Burke (Ellie Hatcher, #3)
Better than book 2 of the series
3 stars
Hatcher & Rogan investigate the killing of a man in a Manhattan penthouse, probably something to do with the tryst that a leftover condom indicates happened. And then they also get the cases of the murder of the roommate of a prostitute and the murder of a different prostitute. Because this is a crime novel, we know all the cases will eventually be connected.
While I found the book better than the second Ellie Hatcher novel, Angel's Tip, 212 falls firmly in the category of average. Nothing is really a surprise here, and nothing is super interesting or particularly bothersome.
Phil in SF finished reading 212 by Alafair Burke (Ellie Hatcher, #3)

212 by Alafair Burke (Ellie Hatcher, #3)
212 is acclaimed author—and former deputy district attorney—Alafair Burke’s gripping thriller featuring hip, Manhattan-based detective Ellie Hatcher. Fans of Lisa …
Phil in SF replied to enne📚's status
@picklish@books.theunseen.city @BEZORP@books.theunseen.city There's an ebook version that was published this year. ISBN: 978-1-938570-36-0
Phil in SF reviewed The Original by Brandon Sanderson
Much action + a dash of what is the government up to
4 stars
The premise is that with some crimes, the best way to catch the original perpetrator is to decant a clone with their memories and tell the clone they have 4 days to find the original or they die. This seems like an odd backdoor method, but after that it's a decent action story. Oh and everyone also is infused with nanites that heal them and "theme" what they see. "Theme" being the term for altering perception to make everything perfect. Despite lots of words focusing on the main character (the clone) being motivated the the original killed their husband (this was the crime) that emotional aspect never really landed for me.
Phil in SF finished reading The Original by Brandon Sanderson

The Original by Brandon Sanderson, Mary Robinette Kowal
Hugo Award–winning authors Brandon Sanderson and Mary Robinette Kowal team up in this exclusive audio-first production of The Original, a …
Phil in SF reviewed No Choice by K. J. Parker
Uninspired short story
2 stars
I've already forgotten the name of the protagonist, but the gist is: prominent noble in standard fare fantasy world is jailed for killing his wife. Son doesn't know what happened, but vows to get father out of jail except he's first being sent to the front lines of an unwinnable war. He draws up plans like a Pepe Silvia meme, wins the war in hours, then high-tails it back to the homeland for poorly written Machiavellian political intrigue to get his dad out of jail. Dad is mad at getting out, confesses to killing wife because she nagged, and then father & son are on opposite sides of more political intrigue.
Poor poor execution on a half-assed idea.
Phil in SF reviewed Build My Gallows High by Geoffrey Homes
The setup baffled me
3 stars
Once the story gets past the beginning chapters and gets into the criminal element in New York, Red Bailey being lined up as a murder suspect there, and then on the run in the Sierra Nevada, it's all fun twists and turns and deception upon deception packed into a mere 153 pages.
The entire setup feels flimsy & convoluted to me. I don't understand what's so special about Mumsie McGonigle that he'd let her go or change his life for her or murder for her, but also not so special that when they split up it's no big deal. Or that he'd not take steps to get rid of evidence that she knows about so that associates of hers can blackmail Red Bailey a decade after the split. But hey, women are mysterious and wiley creatures who magically make men do dumb things, am I right?
Phil in SF started reading 212 by Alafair Burke (Ellie Hatcher, #3)
Phil in SF finished reading No Choice by K. J. Parker

No Choice by K. J. Parker
In this all-new tale, published here for the first time, World Fantasy Award winner K.J. Parker delivers his signature blend …
Phil in SF started reading No Choice by K. J. Parker

No Choice by K. J. Parker
In this all-new tale, published here for the first time, World Fantasy Award winner K.J. Parker delivers his signature blend …
Phil in SF finished reading Build My Gallows High by Geoffrey Homes

Build My Gallows High by Geoffrey Homes
Retired private eye, Red Bailey, is finally happy in Nevada, spending most of his time fishing and tending his out-of-the-way …
Phil in SF reviewed Firstborn by Brandon Sanderson
Doesn't really stick the landing
3 stars
Content warning vague booking about the ending
Dennison is a younger noble raised, unbeknownst to him, to face his brother Varion in battle. Varion has nearly finished conquering the rebellious parts of the empire. The emperor expects Varion to turn and try to become emperor. Thus, Dennison, who is a screw up that can't win any of his battles.
The whole thing is reasonably interesting, except for the abrupt end. One failure should not result like that.











